Key Takeaways
- Lease Only covers marketing, market analysis, tenant screening, lease preparation, a move-in condition report, direct deposit of owner draws and an annual 1099.
- Full Service adds full rent collection, monthly owner statements, maintenance coordination and the owner and tenant online portal.
- Compare the plans on net return, not the line item alone.
- Experienced owners near their rental suit Lease Only, while out-of-state owners and growing portfolios suit Full Service.
Lease Only gets a tenant into your home. Full Service keeps the home running after the tenant moves in. The right choice depends on how many homes you own, how far away they are and how much of the day-to-day you want to carry.
McCaw Property Management offers both plans for single-family rentals across the DFW metroplex. Below we lay out what each plan includes, how to compare cost, and which investors fit which plan.
What Each Plan Covers
The two plans are layers. Everything in Lease Only sits inside Full Service, and Full Service adds the work that starts after move-in.
The Lease Only Plan handles the leasing event from start to finish:
- A market analysis to set the rent.
- Marketing to bring in qualified applicants.
- Tenant screening before anyone signs a lease.
- Lease preparation and a move-in property condition report.
- Direct deposit of owner draws and an annual 1099.

The Full Service Management Plan includes everything above plus full rent collection, move-out condition reports, maintenance coordination, monthly owner statements and the owner and tenant online portal. Renewals, annual condition reports, HVAC tune-ups and eviction services are priced separately, so confirm with us which items fit your situation before you choose.
How to Compare the Cost
Both plans are published on our site, so you see current numbers. Compare them on net return, which is what remains after vacancy, repairs and your own hours.
Lease Only covers less, so the useful question is what you would take on yourself. That means repair calls, vendor invoices and the records you need at tax time. Kyle McCaw invests in rental property himself, so our approach comes from an owner’s view of these tradeoffs.
IRS Publication 527 covers rental income and expenses. A tax professional can tell you how management costs belong on your return.
Who Fits Lease Only
Lease Only suits an investor who has done this before and owns one to three homes within a short drive. You already have a plumber, an HVAC technician and a repair vendor you trust, so what you want from us is the part where a strong start matters most: pricing the home, marketing it and choosing who signs the lease.
Under Lease Only, you handle rent collection after the first month, repairs and renewals, and you keep your own records because the online portal comes with Full Service. If your tenant calls at night about a dead air conditioner in July, that call comes to you.
It also fits a self-managing owner who wants careful screening without handing over everything else. Our post on rental application fraud DFW landlords often overlook shows why a thorough review pays off.

Who Fits Full Service
Full Service suits owners who prefer not to be the first call. That includes people who moved out of state and kept the house, first-time landlords without a vendor list, and investors whose homes are scattered across DFW.
New to renting? Our guide for accidental landlords walks through the responsibilities that come with owning a rental.
Our qualified, experienced vendors and contractors support homes across the metroplex, and the monthly owner statements, direct deposit draws and annual 1099 give you a clean paper trail. Vacancy days are the cost owners overlook most, and the Census Bureau’s Housing Vacancy Survey tracks rental vacancy rates.
Comparison Table
| Investor Profile | Better Fit | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Experienced, one to three homes near Keller | Lease Only | You have vendors and time, and you want marketing and screening. |
| Owner who moved out of state | Full Service | Maintenance coordination, the portal and monthly statements fill the gap. |
| First-time or accidental landlord | Full Service | You gain support with vendors, rent collection and records. |
| Four or more homes across DFW | Full Service | One portal and monthly statements replace spreadsheets. |
| Self-manager who wants stronger screening | Lease Only | Screening strengthens the leasing side while repairs stay with you. |
How DFW Conditions Shape the Choice
We are based in Keller and work across DFW, including Southlake, Grapevine, Flower Mound, Frisco, Denton, Lewisville, Fort Worth, Dallas and Sendera Ranch. Spring and summer are typically busy leasing seasons, so Lease Only owners benefit from having the home rent-ready before the season starts.
Property tax notices arrive in spring and insurance renewals affect cash flow. Those costs stay with you under either plan.

Texas weather also shapes the maintenance load: spring hail and wind, summer heat on HVAC, and winter freezes that affect pipes and irrigation. The NOAA Storm Prediction Center publishes severe storm outlooks to help you plan.
A Decision Rule We Use With Investors
Ask three questions: how many homes, how far away, and how many hours a month you will give to each.
Our rule of thumb is that one missed maintenance call should never cost more than the difference between the plans. A burst pipe on a freeze night or an air conditioner down in August can add a vacancy and a repair bill together, so owners who cannot pick up that call usually choose Full Service.
Slow repairs can lead residents to move on, and our post on top tenant complaints and how to solve them shows how to address them.
For portfolio size, one home near Keller with your own vendors works well on Lease Only. Past four or five homes, the portal and monthly statements replace the spreadsheet you would otherwise build.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Lease Only Mean I Handle Every Repair Myself?
Maintenance coordination is a Full Service item, so under Lease Only the repair side stays with you after move-in. We document the home’s condition in a move-in property condition report. If you choose Lease Only, line up a plumber, an HVAC technician and a general repair vendor before the tenant arrives, because DFW summer heat and winter freezes keep their own schedule.
Which Plan Fits an Out-of-State Investor in DFW?
Full Service usually fits. It gives you maintenance coordination, the owner and tenant online portal, monthly owner statements, an annual 1099 and direct deposit owner draws, so you stay informed from anywhere. Confirm with us which tasks sit with us and which stay with you before you sign.
How Should I Compare the Two Plans on Cost?
Review both plans on our site and compare them on net return instead of the headline line. Add up what Lease Only leaves with you: your hours, vendor invoices, vacancy days and record keeping. Then weigh that against what Full Service takes over, and request our free rental analysis to see what rent the home should command.
How Many Homes Before Full Service Makes Sense?
No set number applies. Distance and spare time decide it sooner than count does: one home in another state calls for Full Service before four homes on your commute do. If you plan to self-manage some homes, our DFW Landlord Survival Book covers the basics of running rentals yourself.
What Should I Have Ready Before You Lease My Home?
Share your HOA name and contact information, and ask the HOA to direct bills and violation notices to our office so we can pay them from your account and notify residents. Our owner FAQ notes that homes are re-keyed and brought to code at the owner’s expense within seven days of move-in, so budget for it early. Confirm the details for your plan with us before you sign.
Talk to Us About Your DFW Rental
If you own a rental anywhere in Dallas-Fort Worth and cannot decide between the two plans, call (817) 491-2553 and choose option 3 for marketing and leasing. You can also get a free rental analysis and we will price the home, then walk through which plan fits your portfolio.
Author
Kyle McCaw is the founder and broker of McCaw Property Management and a Texas licensed real estate broker (License #0562767). He has been investing in and managing single-family rentals across the Dallas–Fort Worth metroplex since 2002, and personally owns a portfolio of single-family rental homes — so the strategy on this page comes from an owner who underwrites the same deals our clients do.
Kyle is an active member of the National Association of Residential Property Managers (NARPM) and has spoken at several national conferences across the single-family rental management and investing industries. McCaw Property Management is rated the #1 property management company in the Roanoke / DFW Metroplex by PropertyManagement.com and has been named to Texas A&M University’s Aggie 100 list of fastest-growing Aggie-owned businesses five times.
McCaw Property Management | 1670 Keller Pkwy, Suite 100, Keller, TX 76248 | 817-491-2553